
The Discomfort of Evening
by Marieke Lucas Rijneveld
This book is the opposite of how I like my life. This book; manure, unwashed skin, and a grief that feels less like a ghost and more like an infection. It made me feel sick, yet I could not look away. Here is why I hated loving The Discomfort of Evening.
Dear Marieke Lucas Rijneveld,
I am writing this to say that I hated your book, yet I could not put it down.
My life is built on clean lines. I previously worked in finance. I spent years making sure columns balance and risk is managed. I still like spreadsheets. Until recently, I like hoping that if X happens, Y will follow. I like my shirts crisp and my boundaries clear.
Your novel is the opposite of all that. It is wet. It is sticky. It smells.
I picked this up expecting a sad story about grief. I was ready for the intellectual version of sadness. You did not give me that. You gave me the biological version. You showed that when a family breaks, it does not just get sad. It gets filthy. The grief in this book isn't a ghost. It is mud, manure, and udder ointment.
The red coat. I need to talk about the red coat.
It started as a piece of clothing and ended up as a second skin. Watching Jas refuse to take it off was excruciating. I found myself actually wanting to reach into the pages to unzip it for her. It was the most effective description of trauma I have ever read. You didn't tell us she was holding onto the past. You just showed us a coat gathering dirt, day after day, until the reader feels as suffocated as she does.
I have to be honest. There were moments I wanted to stop reading. The scene with the soap. The constipation. The way the children try to bargain with death using their own bodies. It was repulsive. However, I realised that my disgust was the price of admission. You refuse to let the reader be a tourist. You force us to live in that house where the parents have mentally checked out and the children have gone feral.
It cured me of any romantic idea about the countryside. City people like me think farms are wholesome. You showed the farm as a brutal machine where things die and things get born and nobody has time to be sentimental about either.
I walked away from this book feeling heavy. I felt like I needed a shower. I suppose that is the point. You wrote a book that bypasses the brain and goes straight to the stomach.
Thank you for the experience, even if it made me feel sick.
With respect,
Tendai Shamu