Financial Discipline Outweighs Raising Capital
Starting a business isn’t just about a brilliant idea bro – it’s about laying the right financial foundation. While conventional wisdom suggests you need a hefty chunk of cash to get going, there's a strong case for how keeping personal expenses in check can be a crucial advantage in today's uncertain economic climate. Let me share a real story that drives this point home.
A man that I know used to be a commercial farmer in South Africa – he ran what appeared to be a thriving agricultural operation. However, beneath it all lay a major vulnerability: high personal expenses, primarily from sending three sons to expensive private schools. While neighbouring farms invested in their operations and built reserves, his business diverted crucial capital to maintain a lifestyle choice. When the 2007-2009 financial crisis hit, compounded by an El Niño weather event, the difference became stark. The neighbouring farms weathered the storm and continue to thrive today. This farmer, lacking the financial cushion and reinvestment that might have protected it, couldn't survive. The consequences were severe: he lost everything, including his home, and now works abroad, separated from his family, hoping to eventually afford a retirement home.*
The intergenerational effects of business setbacks
The irony of those educational expenses is particularly poignant - the private school fees that drained the business ultimately meant there was nothing left for university tuition, especially challenging in a country without government student loan programs and inequality is rampant, higher education often makes or breaks prospects. If Dickens had written Great Expectations in recent times, it would have been about this farmer’s first-born son.
The psychological impact of business failure on future entrepreneurial thinking
Today, this farmer views business opportunities through a completely different lens. Nowadays, he is only interested in ventures promising immediate returns rather than those requiring the time investment that often leads to sustainable success. An understandable but unfortunate shift.
The Broader Lesson
This story isn’t unique to farming or South Africa—it’s universal. Every business model has its own financial demands, and one thing remains constant: flexibility is key.
If you’re starting a service-based business, your main investment might be time rather than money. Manufacturing ventures, on the other hand, often need substantial upfront capital. Whatever your business type, aligning it with your financial reality and building in sustainability is non-negotiable.
For those with higher personal expenses, all hope isn’t lost. You can:
• Reduce expenses gradually.
• Start part-time while keeping your job.
• Choose business models with quicker revenue generation.
The aim is simple: give yourself enough financial breathing room to make smart, strategic decisions rather than desperate ones.
The Takeaway
Financial freedom in entrepreneurship isn’t about being rich or poor—it’s about being smart with your resources. Good money management can make up for other weaknesses in your business, though even the sharpest business minds will struggle to overcome poor financial planning.
Before you jump into your entrepreneurial journey, take these steps:
• Critically evaluate your personal expenses.
• Look for ways to cut fixed costs without sacrificing essentials.
• Build an emergency fund for economic or environmental setbacks.
• Choose a business model that matches your financial reality.
• Focus on sustainable growth over quick profits.
• Remember that today’s lifestyle choices can shape tomorrow’s business resilience.
The most successful businesses often start small, grow slowly, and build strong foundations before scaling up. This disciplined approach is not only safer but also smarter in today’s unpredictable world. Ignoring these principles comes at a cost—not just financial, but one that could shape your family’s future for generations to come.
________
I share what I write with friends or colleagues that I haven’t as yet alienated with my writing. Interestingly, the comment / question that kept coming back from friends who do not work in Financial Services, was; “He should have raised money, either via a loan or selling shares to investors” / “why didn’t he raise capital?”
Let me explaaaain why raising capital isn’t a solution to poor financial management, using this farmers business as a revealing case study.
Think of raising capital like pouring water into a leaking bucket. The core issue isn’t the amount of water (capital) in the bucket, but rather the holes (unsustainable personal expenses) that keep draining it. In the farmer’s case, additional capital wouldn’t have addressed the root problem—the continuous diversion of business resources to cover high personal expenses, such as private school fees.
Here’s why:
The Behavioural Pattern
A founder who habitually draws heavily from the business for personal expenses tends to continue this behaviour when additional capital is introduced. Rather than solving the issue, it often scales the problem. If the farmer had received a cash injection, the prioritisation of personal lifestyle over business reinvestment would likely have persisted, albeit with larger sums involved.
The False Sense of Security
Extra capital can create an illusion of stability, masking underlying financial mismanagement. The neighbouring farmers who weathered both the financial crisis and El Niño did not survive because they had more capital. Their success came down to managing their resources differently. They likely kept personal expenses modest and reinvested in their farms during profitable years.
The Compound Effect
Every dollar (Rand) taken from the business for personal expenses wasn’t just a single withdrawal—it was a missed opportunity. Over time, this had compounding effects, including lost investments in:
Drought-resistant technologies
Emergency reserves
Upgraded farm equipment
Efficiency improvements
The cumulative impact of these missed opportunities widened the gap between the well-managed farms and those that struggled.
Crisis Resilience
When the financial crisis and El Niño struck, the issue wasn’t about access to capital; it was the absence of a financial buffer built through years of disciplined management. Without addressing the management patterns, more initial capital would not have created the buffer needed to survive.
The proof is in the neighbouring farms. They faced the same external challenges, yet they endured because of stronger financial management. Their resilience wasn’t down to having more capital; it stemmed from making better use of what they had. This highlights a key principle in business, particularly in sectors prone to external shocks like agriculture: how resources are managed is far more critical than how much is available.
Note to The Farmer
I’m sharing your story not to criticise, but to offer others a deeper understanding of the complex relationship between personal choices and business resilience. The 2008 recession and El Niño were extraordinary challenges, yet they highlighted how vital it is to build financial buffers during the good times.
Your decision to provide the best education for your children came from a place of love and sacrifice. Even though the long-term consequences were not what you had envisioned, your intentions were rooted in care for your family.
Your experience has taught me valuable lessons about business sustainability—lessons I hope others will also take to heart (if anyone actually reads this blog). I can see why, today, you don’t entertain the idea of ventures that don’t bring immediate returns. Your story reflects not just the difficulties of what went wrong, but also how personal and deeply emotional business decisions can be, particularly when love for family comes into play.
The neighbouring farms did not survive because they were better farmers—you were every bit as skilled. Their resilience came down to different choices about personal expenses and reinvestment. I share this because your story holds invaluable lessons for entrepreneurs navigating similar challenges, helping them find ways to balance their family’s needs with the demands of their business.
This isn’t just a story of a business setback—it’s a story of a father’s love, unforeseen outcomes, and hard-earned lessons that can guide others on their entrepreneurial journey.
*He did have other business attempts.