My name is Tendai Shamu. I am flawed, but I’m learning.
People ask whether venture capital is good for the world. The honest question is not whether it’s “good,” but whether we can build an engine that is allowed to fail without being allowed to be cruel.
Nature is extravagant: most experiments die. Innovation is similar. Many attempts end quietly; a few change the rules. The venture industry borrows Darwin to sound inevitable, but the key difference is this: evolution is blind, capital is a gate. What gets funded is shaped by networks, incentives, fear, and fashion, not only merit.
A friend once joked that investing is “being paid to be wrong in public.” That’s basically true. If you fund the frontier, you will be wrong repeatedly. Popper had the right frame: knowledge advances by surviving attempts to be proven wrong. Venture, at its best, is structured around that embarrassment.
Returns are lopsided. The power law is real. One outcome can justify many failures. That fact explains venture, but it does not excuse it. A system can be economically coherent and morally adolescent at the same time.
I’ve watched a founder shut a company down and tell good people they’d lost their jobs. That’s what critics are pointing at: not failure itself, but our tendency to treat failure like it happens to characters rather than humans.
If venture capital wants to be defensible, it has to be civilised: plan for endings, design dignity into shutdowns, be honest about risk, and take responsibility for how failure lands on people who cannot diversify their lives the way a portfolio can.
Venture is one part of the innovation ecosystem, not the whole thing. Some problems are slow and will not bend to a fund cycle.
So: venture capital is good for the world when it behaves like a gentleman. Not manners, obligations! Progress is not the absence of failure. It is learning without losing our humanity.